Trixie excitedly takes her one-of-a-kind Knuffle Bunny to school to show her friends. Chaos ensues when she discovers, horror of horrors... there's another Knuffle Bunny! Tempers flare, bunnies duel, confiscation occurs... resulting in more trauma mid-night when it is discovered that the bunnies have been inadvertently switched and the two girls are hugging... someone else's Knuffle Bunny!